Discovering How the Qualities Behind Your Success Can Also Hold You Back

Self-Coaching Through Your Character Traits to Recognise Your Strengths begins with the qualities we rely on every day without stopping to notice them.
They shape how we approach problems, how we work with other people and how others come to know us.
They are the reason people trust us with responsibility.
But the same qualities that bring us success in one situation can work against us in another.
For Hank, it began with a conversation he didn’t expect, from someone he hadn’t yet learnt to hear.
He had built his career on one quality above all others, and it had never let him down.
Now it was beginning to cost him the people he needed.
This is the story of how he used self-coaching to recognise his character traits, understand what they made possible and discover qualities in himself that he had almost forgotten were there.
The Man Who Makes the Call
Hank was a construction project director in Denver.
In thirty years, he had worked his way up from carpenter to site manager to the person his company sent in when a project was in trouble.
He was known for one thing above all else.
When everyone else in the room was still debating, Hank made the call.
He could read a site in an afternoon, see where a schedule was slipping and decide what needed to happen next.
Crews trusted him because he never left them waiting for an answer.
Clients trusted him because, when Hank said a project would be back on track, it would be.
That spring, his company merged with one of its largest competitors.
Hank was asked to lead the combined team on the new company’s flagship project, a transit interchange on the edge of the city, connecting the light rail, bus routes and a new public square.
It was the largest project of his career.
It was also four months behind schedule.
The two companies had worked in different ways for decades, and their people didn’t yet trust one another.
Meetings ran long.
Decisions stalled.
Hank did what he had always done.
He listened to the first few minutes of each discussion, saw where it was heading and made the decision himself.
The project was quickly moving again.
The merged company’s board would decide in the autumn who would lead its project teams across the region.
Hank had every reason to believe he was showing them exactly what they needed.
A Warning He Didn’t Expect
Rosa was the project’s lead structural engineer.
She had come from the other company, where she had led some of its most complex projects, and she knew the interchange’s design better than anyone.
One Thursday, at the end of a site meeting, she asked Hank for five minutes.
They stood by the site office as the crews packed up for the day.
She told him, calmly, that she was considering leaving.
Hank was genuinely surprised.
The project was moving again, and Rosa was central to it.
She explained.
Three times that month, she had raised a concern in front of her team, and three times he had decided the matter before she finished speaking.
Once, he had been right.
Twice, she believed he had been wrong, and her team had watched her concerns set aside.
“You’re very good at making decisions,” she said. “But my team has stopped bringing me problems, because they think you’ll decide them anyway.”
Hank started to explain why the decisions had been necessary.
Then he noticed he was doing it again.
He told her he would think about what she had said.
That evening, at dinner, his wife, Diane, asked him about his day.
He told her about the schedule, the crane hire and the inspection due the following week.
He didn’t mention Rosa.
When Diane suggested they spend the weekend at the cabin her family owned in the mountains, Hank had already worked out the route, the timings and who would do the shopping before she finished the sentence.
Diane put down her fork.
“You’ve started running this house like one of your sites,” she said.
She said it lightly.
But Hank heard the same thing he had heard from Rosa that afternoon.
Two people who knew him in completely different ways had told him the same thing on the same day.
He couldn’t put it down to a difficult engineer, or to a tired evening.
The quality that had built his career was doing something he hadn’t noticed.
Asking Himself Different Questions
Hank’s first instinct was to solve the problem the way he solved every problem.
He would make a decision.
He would let Rosa finish speaking in meetings, count to five before he answered and move on.
But he had a feeling that a rule like that wouldn’t last a week on a busy site.
He needed to understand what was happening before he decided what to do about it.
It was an unfamiliar order of things for him.
That weekend, at the cabin, he sat on the porch early in the morning before Diane was up and opened the notebook he used for site visits.
On a clean page, he wrote down the questions he wanted to answer.
Which qualities have brought me the greatest success?
When do those qualities help the people around me, and when do they get in their way?
What do Rosa and Diane see that I don’t?
Are there qualities I have, but rarely use?
The questions were harder to answer than he expected.
He knew what he was good at, but he had never thought of it as a character trait.
It was simply the way he was.
He decided to look at his experience.
Years earlier, on a leadership course his company had run, a facilitator had asked everyone to write three stories from their working lives: a Success Story, a Passion Story and a Failure Story.
Hank had written them quickly and never looked at them again.
Now he wondered what they might show him about his character, if he wrote them properly.
For each one, he would describe the Situation, What He Did and What It Revealed about the traits he had drawn on.
His Success Story
Hank began with the story he had told more often than any other.
The Situation: Fifteen years ago, I was managing the construction of a road bridge over the South Platte River. Two days before a major concrete pour, a storm upstream sent the river rising faster than anyone had forecast.
What I Did: I called off the pour, moved the equipment to higher ground overnight and rebuilt the schedule so we lost four days instead of four weeks.
What It Revealed: I’m decisive. I stay calm under pressure, and I take responsibility for the call.
He read it back.
It was true, and he was proud of it.
But he remembered what the facilitator on the course had said: the first version of a Success Story tends to describe the outcome, and the traits sit in the detail.
So he asked himself a different question.
What exactly did I do in the hour before I made the call?
He closed his eyes and went back to the riverbank.
He had stood with Earl, the bridge foreman, who had worked on that river for twenty years.
Hank had asked him what he had seen the river do before.
Earl had told him about a flood in the nineties that had come up overnight with almost no warning.
Hank had asked the crane operator how long it would take to move the equipment, and the concrete supplier how much notice they needed to cancel.
Only then had he made the call.
He had forgotten that part completely.
He rewrote the last section.
What It Revealed: I’m decisive, I stay calm under pressure and I take responsibility for the call. But my best decision came after I had listened to the people who knew more than I did. My decisiveness was strongest when it followed curiosity.
Hank looked at the word curiosity for a long time.
He wouldn’t have used it to describe himself.
Yet there it was, in the middle of the story he was proudest of.
His Passion Story
Next, Hank turned to a decision he had stood by when it would have been easier to give way.
The Situation: Eight years ago, on an office development downtown, a scaffold inspection found faults on the east side of the building. The client was under pressure to open on time and wanted us to keep working on the other three sides while the repairs were made.
What I Did: I shut the whole site for two days. I told the client that no one on my crew would work under scaffolding I wasn’t sure of, and I took the calls from the developer’s lawyers myself so my site manager didn’t have to.
What It Revealed: I’m protective of the people who work for me. I won’t put them at risk to meet a deadline, and I’ll take the pressure so they don’t have to.
Hank read the story with quiet satisfaction.
He would make the same decision again tomorrow.
Then he asked himself a question he had never asked about this story.
Where else does this trait show up in the way I work?
The answer came uncomfortably quickly.
He protected people from risk.
He also protected them from difficult decisions, from long meetings and from the discomfort of not knowing what would happen next.
When Rosa’s team raised a problem, he took it from them and solved it.
He had always thought of that as looking after his people.
Now he wondered whether, to Rosa’s team, it felt like being told their judgement didn’t count.
He wrote one more line beneath the story.
My protectiveness is one of my best qualities. But when I protect people from every decision, I also take away their chance to make one.
His Failure Story
Hank had to think for a while before he could choose a Failure Story.
He had made plenty of mistakes in thirty years, but he had always fixed them and moved on.
Then he remembered the parking structure.
He wrote the version he had told himself at the time.
The Situation: Five years ago, we were building a multi-storey parking structure on a tight site in Aurora. The ground conditions turned out to be worse than the survey had shown.
What I Did: I kept the project moving and dealt with the problems as they came up.
What It Revealed: You can’t control the ground.
He read it back and felt uneasy.
It was the shortest of his three stories, and it left out the part he least wanted to remember.
He asked himself:
What happened, step by step?
Who else was there, and how would they tell it?
What part did my own traits play?
The details came back slowly.
Danny, a new site engineer who had been with the company less than a year, had come to him with a concern about groundwater on the north side.
He wanted to run further tests before the foundations were poured.
The tests would have taken a week.
Hank had listened for about a minute, looked at the schedule and told him to proceed.
Three weeks after the pour, water began coming through the lower level.
The repairs took a month and cost far more than the tests would have.
Danny never raised another concern with him.
Six months later, he left the company.
Hank wrote the story again.
The Situation: Five years ago, on a parking structure in Aurora, Danny, a new site engineer, raised a concern about groundwater and asked for a week to run further tests before the foundations were poured.
What I Did: I listened for about a minute, looked at the schedule and told him to proceed. The water came through three weeks later. The repairs took a month. Danny stopped bringing me problems and left within the year.
What It Revealed: My decisiveness, the trait behind my greatest success, was behind this failure too. I decided before I understood. My impatience turned a strength into a weakness, and it cost me a good engineer who had been trying to help me.
Hank sat back.
Danny had stopped bringing him problems.
Rosa’s team had stopped bringing her problems.
It was the same story, five years apart.
The only difference was that this time, someone had told him before it was too late.
A Second World
A few weeks earlier, Hank’s sister, Joanne, had asked him for a favour.
Joanne ran a small community theatre in north Denver, in a converted church hall.
Its summer production was Twelve Angry Men, and she needed someone to build the jury room set.
Hank had agreed, because building things was what he did and because it was hard to say no to Joanne.
He spent his Saturday mornings in the hall, building a long table, twelve chairs and a set of tall windows that would look out onto a painted city.
Six weeks before opening night, one of the actors moved away for work.
Joanne asked Hank to step in.
He laughed and said no.
She asked again, and reminded him that she had heard him reading the jurors’ lines aloud on Saturday mornings while he tested the furniture.
He said yes.
The director, Marcus, cast him as one of the jurors who says little at first and changes his mind slowly, as he listens to the arguments around the table.
At his first rehearsal, Hank did what he did on site.
He came in early with his lines, jumped ahead of the other actors and suggested how the scene should be staged.
Marcus stopped the rehearsal and took him aside.
“In this play, the audience watches the people who are listening,” he said. “Your job in this scene is to listen. Really listen. Let the others finish, and let us see you take it in.”
Hank found it surprisingly difficult.
But over the following rehearsals, something changed.
He began to notice the small shifts in the other actors’ voices, the moment someone’s confidence wavered and the moment an argument landed.
Marcus told him he had become the most watchable person at the table.
In the breaks, Hank found himself making the cast laugh with stories from building sites.
One of the cast, a first-time actor who was terrified of forgetting her lines, told Joanne that Hank was the reason she had stopped dreading rehearsals.
On the drive home one evening, Hank told Diane about it.
She smiled.
“You used to be like that all the time,” she said. “When we built this house, you’d sit with the plumber for an hour, asking him how he’d do it. The crews used to say you told the best stories at lunch.”
Hank had forgotten that too.
The theatre hadn’t turned him into someone new.
It had shown him qualities he already had: curiosity, patience, attentiveness and a humour that put people at ease.
On site, he had stopped using them, because decisiveness had always been enough.
Giving Himself Effective Self-Feedback
Hank now had three stories and a rehearsal room full of observations.
He needed to test what he thought he was learning, rather than simply accept it.
For the next week on site, he watched himself.
In every meeting, he made a small mark in his notebook each time he made a decision before the person speaking had finished.
By Friday, there were twenty-three marks.
He also noted what happened afterwards.
When the decision was simple and urgent, his speed helped everyone.
When the problem was complicated, or when the person speaking knew more than he did, the room went quiet, and the conversation ended with his answer instead of the best one.
Then he asked himself the questions he had used with his stories.
Where am I being too harsh with myself?
Where am I being too generous?
What would the people who know me best say I’ve missed?
He recognised that he had been tempted to swing too far.
After Rosa’s warning, part of him had begun to think that his decisiveness was the problem, and that he needed to become a different kind of leader altogether.
The evidence didn’t support that.
Crews relied on him to make the call.
The bridge project would have been lost without it.
The scaffold decision had kept people safe.
But he had also been too generous with himself for years.
He had told himself that deciding quickly was always a service to others, when sometimes it was simply impatience.
He asked Diane what she thought he had missed.
She told him that he made decisions for other people because he cared about them, but that it didn’t always feel like care from the other side.
Hank wrote down what he could now see.
His strongest traits were decisiveness, calm under pressure and protectiveness.
They had built his career, and he had no intention of losing them.
When he was impatient, decisiveness became deciding too soon, and protectiveness became taking decisions away from people.
And he had other traits he had stopped using at work: curiosity, patience, attentiveness and humour.
His stories and the rehearsal room had shown him that his best decisions came when those traits worked together.
Effective self-feedback had given him a fuller picture of his character: what he did well, where it worked against him and what he could bring back.
Seeing His Strengths Differently
Hank returned to the questions he had written on the porch.
Which qualities have brought me the greatest success?
He could answer that more fully now.
His decisiveness had brought him success, but it had worked best when curiosity and patience came first.
When do those qualities get in the way?
When impatience took over, and he decided before he understood.
What do Rosa and Diane see that I don’t?
That his care for people sometimes looked like control.
Are there qualities I have, but rarely use?
He had found four of them in the rehearsal room.
Curiosity, patience, attentiveness and a humour that put people at ease.
Hank realised he didn’t need to become less decisive.
He needed to change the order in which he used his traits.
On the bridge project, he had been curious first, patient enough to listen and decisive at the end.
On the parking structure, he had skipped straight to the end.
On Monday morning, he asked Rosa if she had time for a coffee.
He didn’t explain or defend.
He told her she had been right to speak to him, and that he had been thinking about what she had said.
Then he asked her about the two decisions she believed he had got wrong.
He listened while she talked him through them, and he asked questions until he understood her reasoning.
On the first, he still thought his decision had been right, and he told her why.
On the second, the sequencing of the steel for the station canopy, he realised she was right.
“What would you do?” he asked.
She told him.
“Then that’s what we’ll do,” he said. “And from now on, the canopy is your call.”
Rosa didn’t tell him she would stay.
She said she would see how the next few weeks went.
Hank understood.
One conversation couldn’t undo the past few months.
At the project meeting that afternoon, he waited until everyone else had spoken before he gave his view.
It felt slow and unfamiliar.
Twice, he had to stop himself from interrupting.
But when Rosa’s team raised a problem with the drainage on the public square, they looked at her, not at him.
That evening, Hank went to rehearsal.
Opening night was three weeks away.
As he sat at the long table he had built, listening to the other jurors argue, he thought about how much of the play depended on a few people being willing to listen long enough to change their minds.
Using Your Character Traits to Recognise Your Strengths
The qualities that bring you success are worth understanding as clearly as the skills you have worked to develop.
They shape how you make decisions, how you respond under pressure and how the people around you experience working with you.
Self-coaching can help you see them more fully.
Your Success Stories can show you the traits behind your best work, and the detail of those stories may reveal qualities you hadn’t noticed.
Your Passion Stories can show you what you will stand by, and help you ask where else those traits appear in the way you work.
Your Failure Stories can show you what happens when a strength is overused, or when it works without the qualities that usually balance it.
Insightful self-questions help you look beyond your first account of an experience.
Observation helps you notice what your traits do in the moment, and effective self-feedback helps you weigh what you see without dismissing your strengths or excusing their costs.
And a second world, outside your working life, can show you qualities you already have but have stopped using.
Enhancing your character traits can begin with recognising the full range of what you bring, and choosing which traits a situation needs, and in what order.
In the next story, Self-Coaching Through Your Character Traits to Meet Your Challenges, Hank faces a crisis on site in the same week the play opens, and discovers whether he can draw on every side of his character when the pressure rises. (Coming soon)
Then, in Self-Coaching Through Your Character Traits to Grow as a Leader, Hank takes on a new role and helps others recognise and develop their own traits. (Coming soon)
Continue the Work
If Hank’s story has prompted you to reflect on your own working life, these resources offer different ways to recognise your character traits, understand how they work for you and against you, and develop the qualities you want to bring to your work.
Explore Enhance Your Character Traits — stories and reflections on the character traits that shape how we work, lead and respond to challenges.
Explore The Art of WorkLife Storytelling — Discover how the stories we tell about our experiences can help us understand ourselves, recognise what matters and use what we learn to shape our working lives
Explore Enhance Your Character Traits Story Lessons — practical, story-based resources that help you recognise your traits, understand what they make possible and develop them in your working life.
Explore Enhance Your Character Traits Programmes — Follow a guided learning journey to explore your character traits, recognise when a strength is working against you and draw on the full range of qualities you bring.
Explore Professional Self-Coaching Resources — Work through focused resources that help you ask yourself the right questions, find your own answers and take action on what you learn.
Explore Individual WorkLife Coaching — when you need space to think with someone else about your working life, a difficult situation, a decision or what comes next, dedicated coaching sessions help you explore what matters, see your situation differently and find your own way forward.
Work With Me: Individual WorkLife Coaching, Commissioned Learning Resources, Speaking Engagements and Organisational Partnerships
Support This Work: Your support makes a difference and helps me to continue creating resources that are accessible to everyone. Thank you. Carmel
Listen to the audio version here:
Share This Piece
If this piece resonated with you, or made you think of someone who might appreciate it, please share it forward.
