The Frameworks Tell Us What Development Looks Like — Stories Tell Us What It Means
Why Professional Development Needs Stories.
Levi did not trust stories at work.
He would never have said so out loud. But he thought them soft. Anecdotal. A pleasant way to fill the gap between the parts of a session that actually did the work.
The parts that did the work, in Levi’s view, were the frameworks.
He had spent years building them. Competency models. Development ladders. Behavioural indicators, carefully worded so that anyone could read them and know exactly where they stood and what the next step required. He was good at it. When someone came to him unsure of how to grow, he could show them — precisely, on a single page — what growth looked like.
He believed in that page.
He believed that if you could name a capability clearly enough, and describe what it looked like at each level, a person could see where they were and move deliberately towards where they wanted to be.
And for a long time, that belief served him well.
The Person The Framework Couldn’t Reach
Then he was asked to develop someone.
Her name was Katherine, and by every measure Levi trusted, she should have been progressing. She was capable. She was conscientious. She understood the work. But she had stalled at a particular point, and Levi could not quite say why.
The framework was clear about what the next level required. Katherine needed to speak up in the rooms where decisions were made. To bring her judgement into the open instead of keeping it to herself and delivering it, perfectly, only when asked.
Levi did what Levi did.
He sat down with her and took out the page.
He showed her the competency. He described what it looked like at her current level, and what it would look like at the next. He pointed to the specific behaviours: contributing early, offering a view before being invited to, disagreeing openly when she saw something others had missed. He was clear. He was precise. He was, he thought, genuinely helpful.
Katherine listened.
She nodded in the right places.
She said, “That makes sense.”
And nothing changed.
Levi went back to the framework. Perhaps he hadn’t been clear enough. He refined the language. He added examples. He broke the behaviour down into smaller, more visible steps — in the next meeting, offer one view in the first ten minutes.He did this well. He did this thoroughly.
And still, nothing changed.
It was not that Katherine disagreed with anything he had told her. She could have recited it back to him word for word. She knew exactly what the next level of capability looked like.
She simply could not seem to become it.
The Thing He Said Without Meaning To
It happened almost by accident.
They were sitting together after another conversation that had gone nowhere, and Levi, tired and slightly out of ideas, stopped reaching for the page.
He said, “Can I tell you about someone I worked with years ago?”
Katherine looked up.
He hadn’t planned to. He wasn’t even sure why he had. But now that it was out, he kept going.
“There was a woman on a team I supported early in my career. Brilliant — quietly, the sharpest person in the room. And in every meeting she’d sit with the answer already worked out and say nothing. Afterwards, walking back to her desk, she’d tell me the thing that would have changed the whole discussion. Every time. So one day I asked her why she never said it in the room. And she told me something I’ve never forgotten. She said, ‘If I say it and I’m wrong, everyone sees I was wrong. If I say nothing and they get it wrong, at least I still know I was right.'”
Levi paused.
“She’d built a whole career out of being right in private. It felt safe. It felt like integrity, even. But it meant her best thinking never reached anyone who could use it. And the day she finally understood that — that keeping her judgement to herself wasn’t modesty, it was a way of never being caught out — was the day she started to change. Not because someone told her to speak. Because she saw what her silence was actually costing, and what it was actually protecting.”
He stopped.
For the first time in weeks, Katherine was not nodding politely.
She was very still.
“I do that,” she said quietly. “I always know afterwards. In the corridor. Never in the room.”
And Levi realised, with something close to discomfort, that he had just reached in two minutes a place the framework had not reached in two months.
What The Framework Had Been Missing
Later, Levi tried to work out what had happened.
He was not ready to abandon the framework. He still believed in it. The page had not been wrong. Everything on it was accurate. The competency was real. The behaviours were the right behaviours. Contribute early. Offer a view before being invited to. All true.
But the page had described the destination without ever describing the journey.
It could tell Katherine what the capability looked like from the outside.
It could not tell her what stood in the way of it on the inside — the private arithmetic of a person who had decided, long ago, that being right in silence was safer than being wrong out loud.
And that was the very thing she had needed to recognise.
Because Katherine had not been stuck for lack of information.
She had been stuck inside something she couldn’t yet see — and the framework, for all its precision, had no way of reaching inside it. It could label the outside of development. It could not open the inside of it.
The story could.
The story reached the place the framework couldn’t go, because the story was made of the same material as the thing Katherine was actually living.
The Same Person, A Different Moment
Here is where Levi expected the work to become easy.
He had found the thing that worked. Katherine had recognised herself. Surely now he could simply keep telling stories, and she would keep changing.
That was not what happened.
Katherine did begin to speak in meetings. Tentatively at first, then more. But a few weeks in, she came to Levi frustrated. She had started contributing — and twice now it had gone badly. She had offered a view, been challenged hard, and folded. She had said the thing in the corridor again, but this time it was I tried, and it didn’t work.
Levi began, instinctively, to reach for another story.
And then he stopped.
Because a story was not what this moment needed.
Katherine no longer needed to recognise something hidden. She had recognised it. What she needed now was something the story could not give her — the concrete, unsentimental mechanics of how. How to hold a view under challenge. How to distinguish a real objection from a reflexive one. How to say “let me come back to that” instead of collapsing.
So Levi took out the page.
And this time, the framework landed. The same page that had done nothing two months earlier now did exactly what it was built to do — because the ground had been cleared for it. Katherine no longer heard it as an abstract description of someone she couldn’t become. She heard it as instructions for something she had already started to do and wanted to do better.
The story had opened the door.
The framework, brought back at the right moment, showed her how to walk through it.
The Wall The Framework Couldn’t Move
Levi thought he had it now. Story to open the door. Framework to walk through it. A sequence he could trust.
Then Katherine hit a third wall, and it was unlike the others.
She had taken on something genuinely beyond her current level — a piece of work with her name on it, visible, consequential, the kind of thing the next stage of her career would be built on. And she had frozen. Not the quiet freeze of the meeting room this time. A deeper one. She came to Levi and said, almost flatly, that she thought she had made a mistake taking it on. That she wasn’t the person people seemed to think she was. That she’d been found out.
Levi reached for the page.
It was the obvious move — show her the map, show her the ground was known, break the thing into steps. He started to. And he watched it do nothing at all. Worse than nothing. Every clean, reassuring line on the page seemed to land on her as one more measure she was failing to meet.
He put the page down.
And he understood that this was the moment he had been circling for months without recognising it. Because he had been here himself. Years ago. In exactly this place.
So he told her.
“I need to tell you about the worst month of my working life,” he said. “I’d been given something I’d wanted for years, and the moment I had it, I was certain I couldn’t do it. Not nervous — certain. I’d lie awake composing the email that admitted I wasn’t up to it. I never sent it, but I wrote it in my head most nights. And the thing that kept me stuck wasn’t the work. The work was doable. It was that I’d decided the fear was information. I thought feeling like a fraud meant I was one.”
Katherine was watching him now.
“What got me out wasn’t a plan,” Levi said. “Someone I trusted told me about the time they’d felt exactly the same — described that email, the one you write in your head at three in the morning, word for word. And I remember the relief of it, physically. Not because they’d solved anything. Because I understood, for the first time, that the feeling was something people had on the way into work that stretched them — not proof they should turn back. It was a threshold, not a verdict.”
He paused.
“I couldn’t have read that off a page. I needed to hear it had happened to someone who came out the other side.”
Katherine didn’t say anything for a while. Then she said, “You wrote the email too.”
“Every night for a month,” Levi said.
And something in her let go.
Only afterwards — days afterwards, once the worst of it had passed — did the framework become useful again, when Katherine was ready to break the work into the concrete steps that would actually carry her across.
Story first, this time. His own story. The framework second.
The opposite order from the wall before. The same person.
What He Finally Understood
Levi had believed, for years, that the question was: framework or story?
It wasn’t.
He had then believed, briefly, that the answer was a sequence — story first, framework second — a new rule to replace the old one.
That wasn’t it either. Because the walls kept coming in a different order. Sometimes the framework had to land before a story could move her. Sometimes only a story could reach a place the framework made worse. Same person. Same developer. Different day, different need.
And that was the thing Levi finally understood.
It had never been about choosing the right tool once and for all. It had never even been about the right order. It was about the person in front of him, on this particular day, carrying this particular thing — and reading what this moment was asking for.
The skill was never the tool.
The skill was the reading.
Why This Is Not A Choice Between The Two
The framework and the story were never rivals. They were doing two different jobs, and neither could do the other’s.
The framework named the capability. Without it, Levi’s stories would have been just stories — nice moments, warmly received, quickly forgotten. What made them land was that Katherine could take what she recognised and place it onto something solid. She could say: that feeling has a name, and the name is on the page, and now I know what the page was actually asking of me.
The framework told her what.
The story told her why, and how, and what it felt like along the way.
The framework was the map.
The story was the territory the map had always been describing — and until she had walked a little of that territory, through her own experience or someone else’s, the map had been a drawing of a country she had never visited.
That was the discovery.
Not that stories replace frameworks.
That stories are what make frameworks true.
A competency model is a set of claims about how people develop. A story is what lets a person feel one of those claims from the inside and recognise it as their own. Without the story, the framework stays a description of someone else. Without the framework, the story stays a moment that touched her and led nowhere.
Each one made the other usable.
Why Professional Development Needs Stories
People do not change because they have been told, accurately, what change looks like.
They change when they recognise themselves inside an experience — their own, or someone else’s — and see, from the inside, what a different response might have been, and might yet be.
That recognition is not something a framework can manufacture.
It is something a story makes possible.
Because a story does what an abstraction cannot.
Courage is an idea until we watch someone decide whether to speak.
Judgement is an idea until we watch someone weigh being wrong out loud against being right in silence, and choose.
Capability is an idea until we see someone certain they’ve been found out, and then watch them discover the fear was a threshold and not a verdict.
The framework can name all of these.
Only the story can let us feel them — and it is the feeling, not the naming, that moves a person from knowing about development to actually developing.
Levi still keeps the framework.
He still believes in it.
But he no longer assumes it is where every conversation begins. Before he reaches for anything, he does the thing that turned out to matter most.
He looks at the person in front of him — the same person he may have sat with a dozen times before — and he asks himself what this moment, today, is really asking for.
Sometimes the answer is the framework.
Sometimes the answer is a story.
Often it is both, and the whole art is knowing which comes first.
The framework tells us what development looks like.
The story tells us what it means.
And knowing which a person needs, in a given moment, is itself the deeper professional development — the one no page, on its own, could ever have taught him.
Connect and Continue
Work With Me: Commissioned learning resources, speaking engagements, and organisational partnerships.
Support This Work: Your support makes a difference and helps me to continue creating resources that are accessible to everyone. Thank you. Carmel
Listen to the audio version here:
Share This Piece
If this piece resonated with you, or made you think of someone who might appreciate it, please share it forward.
Discover more from schoolofworklife.com
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.